I have been asked to write
an article about some of the important aspects of judging based
on my experience
as a judge in the United
States. I would like to share a few ideas from a judge’s
point of view which I think could be interesting for readers of
all experience levels. For the purpose of this article, we will
focus on a Classic Fino category, one that is highly prized in
this sport.
When we look at a horse as
a judge, and there may not be a more important point than this,
the first
thing we look at is the overall
package, that is, the horse in total. For example, I look for elegance,
execution and beauty. So, if a horse has a defect, even one that
receives a scoring penalty, don’t let that one problem divert
your attention from the overall performance of the horse. Always
remember to judge with the overall picture in mind.
After that, I begin to study
the horse part by part. One of the judging points that first
calls my attention
is the speed of the
feet. For those of you who may be new to the sport, when I talk
about speed, I’m referring to the speed of the up and down
motion of the horse’s hooves similar to the pistons in your
car’s engine or the needle of a sewing machine. And, if we
were to create a speed scale from one to seven with one being the
slowest and seven being the fastest, we would want the speed of
the Classic Fino’s feet to be at level seven, the fastest.
However, speed isn’t everything, so let’s break things
down a little further.
The next point of discussion
is the proper action of the front feet. There are various technical
terms or it. Traditionally, it
has been called “Finura” or the sharpness of the foot
striking the riding surface, others call it “Timbre” like
the firm action of someone hitting papers with a stamp at the office.
Still others call it “Rapides” for the speed or quickness
of the front feet. Again for those of you who aren’t experienced,
it’s as if we were looking at the action at the end of a
whip as it cracks quickly downward. Another analogy might be the
rapid, spinning motion of the drive wheels of a railroad locomotive
when its power is released but the wheels haven’t gained
traction yet.
Along with the speed and firmness
of the front feet, some consider part of the proper action to
be
the lowness of the stop. In other
words, the horse should not raise its front feet very far off the
riding surface. I do think there’s some truth to this but
it’s not always the case. For example, in one horse is low
and slow and another is high and fast the one that is high and
fast has a better chance to place than the one that is low and
slow, even in a Fino class. So speed plays an important role, not
only in competition, but also in every facet of these animals.
For example, speed is important in choosing a breeding animal,
it increases the appraisal value of any animal. It’s a major
determining factor in the value of young animals and it raises
the level of placement in all other categories such as performance
and pleasure. I won’t go into detail here because that would
be a topic for another time.
We begin with the front of
the horse so now let’s talk about
the speed and action of the hind legs and feet. They are important
for a number of reasons which I will list in no particular order
of importance. The hind legs and feet are the “motor” of
the horse. Those of us who have had the opportunity to ride one
of these animals with good posterior movement can attest to this.
In judging the hind legs and
feet, we first look for the piston-like action of the hocks.
In some
cases, this action isn’t expressed
well when the horse is fully collected, yet we can still feel it
through the power of the impact of the feet upon the riding surface.
Once again, like speed, it plays an important role in judging.
Sometimes, the force that is displayed in this movement can be
seen in a different way. For Example, when the rear feet properly
execute this action, dirt or grass is thrown backwards. On other
occasions, like on hard surfaces, the horse’s feet slide
to the rear in a swooping action or as if it were skating backwards.
Now it’s time to talk about “Collection”, that
is, bringing into proper line all the parts of the horse in motion.
This plays an important role, especially in the United States because
it is part of the requirements for the Classic Fino. It is my humble
opinion, however, that there are times when we have to sacrifice “collection” if
the individual virtues of a horse that is not quite as collected
surpass those of a more collected one. For example, if one horse
isn’t as well collected as another but has better speed,
is quieter in the hind quarters, has a better vertical appearance
(plumb line), is more elegant, and has more beauty, there is sufficient
reason to place the horse that isn’t as well collected higher.
But to keep a proper perspective, remember that collection tells
a lot about a horse because the majority of extraordinary Finos
down through history have been collected.
At this point, let me interject
a few words about a very critical element in competition. What
I am
talking about now is the rhythm
of the Paso Fino gait. What we listen for here is the “taca,
taca, taca” sound of the hooves in a coordinated rhythm.
Remember, too, if a horse veers toward the diagonal (troche) or
the lateral (pace), it loses its opportunity to earn a good score
in the competition. In fact, without a proper Paso Fino rhythm
in gait, a horse cannot win a competition.
Let’s continue with a few other points although, perhaps,
not quite as important as the ones we’ve already discussed.
• The croup, i.e. hind quarters, should be as quiet as possible
in a competition horse. By that I mean, they shouldn’t move
from side to side or up and down. Naturally, we should always penalize
an unsteady croup. Now, let me discuss a couple of situations that
can give you further insight into this point. In the first situation,
let’s say there is a horse that is extraordinary overall,
yet it has some movement in the croup. Its competitor is a mediocre
horse with no movement in the croup. In this case, he horse that
is extraordinary overall should place higher than the mediocre
one. The second is a situation where we have two outstanding horses.
The first one has a higher overall rating but has an unsteady croup.
The second, has a lower overall rating, but has a superior croup.
In this case, the second horse, with the better croup, should place
higher.
• A horse should always
react properly to the demands of the rider. It should not break
gait
either by a change in rhythm
or a jump (lurch) forward.
• A horse should have a proper vertical alignment (plumb
line) of its front legs and feet. I look for three key areas that
I’ll rank in order of importance. 1). its front feet shouldn’t
cross in front of each other 2). Its feet should not toe (point)
in or toe out instead of being lined up in the direction the horse
is going nor should its feet “wing out”. (Winging out
occurs when a horses feet go outside of its line of forward movement
in a swimming-like motion)
Judging a Classic Fino competition demands a lot from the horse,
rider and judge. And of course, in such a limited space we cannot
deliver total justice to the complex art of judging. However, I
hope that the ideas I have presented here have been of value to
you and can enhance the way in which you view your next competition
whatever your level of experience and knowledge may be.
Ernie Sanz